logo

OLD AGE PENSIONS- ALTERNATIVE MOVEMENTS gggff

 

cartoon of butcher
This cartoon, from the Townsend Plan's "Weekly" newspaper, expresses the group's main objection to Social Security--that it was not generous enough in the benefits it offered. The Townsend Plan promised every senior citizen $200 per month , regardless of past earnings. Under the social insurance program of the Social Security Act a worker whose earnings averaged $100 month for 40 years would collect a Social Security retirement benefit of only $35 month. This gave the Townsend Plan an immediate appeal, which is reflected in the cartoon. (Keep in mind, however, that economists estimated it would require one-half of the nation's total income to fund the level of benefits promised by Townsend!)